Home/KiwiSaver Guides/Active vs passive

Active vs passive KiwiSaver funds

A passive fund tracks the market. It follows a market index and holds the same investments in the same proportions as that index. For shares, that could be a share index such as the S&P 500, the MSCI World Index or the S&P/NZX 50. For bonds, it could be a bond index such as the Bloomberg Global Aggregate Index, which covers government and corporate bonds from around the world. A diversified passive KiwiSaver fund, such as a balanced or growth fund, simply combines share and bond index funds in set proportions. No one is deciding which companies or bonds to buy, and when the index changes, the fund rebalances to match.

An active fund tries to beat the index (market). A manager and their team research companies, hold more of the ones they believe will do well, avoid the ones they don't, and adjust as conditions change. The goal is to end up ahead of the index rather than matching it.

Put simply: a passive fund accepts the market return and keeps costs down. An active fund pays for the attempt to do better.

Who are the passive and active managers?

Passive (index) providers

These providers mainly build funds that track a market index, keeping fees among the lowest in the market.

  • AMP
  • ANZ
  • ASB
  • Kernel
  • Simplicity
  • Westpac

Active managers

These managers use investment teams to choose what to hold, aiming to beat the index and cushion the blow when markets fall.

  • BNZ
  • Booster
  • Fisher Funds
  • Generate
  • GoalsGetter (Amova)
  • Milford
  • Pathfinder
  • QuayStreet

See our Best KiwiSaver Providers guide for more on each provider.

Why the fees differ

The gap in fees is not a pricing decision so much as a reflection of what each approach costs to run.

An active fund has people to pay

Analysts, portfolio managers, economists and traders all sit behind an actively managed fund. Someone has to research companies, visit them, model their earnings and decide what to buy. That salary bill is real, it recurs every year, and it is charged to the fund whether or not the decisions turn out well.

An active fund trades far more

Acting on a view means buying and selling. Every trade carries brokerage and the spread between buying and selling prices. A fund that turns over much of its portfolio each year pays those costs repeatedly. An index fund trades mainly when the index itself changes, or when money comes in and out.

A passive fund follows a rule

Once the index is chosen, the fund is largely mechanical. No research team, minimal trading, and the same process whether the fund holds $50 million or $5 billion, so the cost can be spread very thin.

The whole debate comes down to one question: does the extra you pay for active management reliably buy you extra return?

The bit nobody mentions: "passive" funds still make active decisions

A fund can track an index perfectly and still have had a great many judgement calls made on your behalf:

  • Which index? Global developed markets, or global including emerging? That's a real bet.
  • How much in shares at all? The split between growth and income assets is an active choice, and it's the biggest driver of your outcome.
  • Currency hedging. How much of the overseas exposure is hedged back to NZ dollars moves returns significantly, and it's a decision someone made.
  • Exclusions. Most "passive" KiwiSaver funds screen out weapons, tobacco and so on. That's a departure from the index, by choice.

Not all passive funds are equal. Two passive growth funds can produce quite different returns because of these choices. One might hold more in shares, track a different index, hedge less of its overseas exposure or exclude more companies. Fees also vary between passive providers, and so does how closely each fund actually tracks its index. When you compare passive funds, look at the mix of assets, the indices they follow and their long-term returns after fees, not just the fact that they are labelled "passive".

Reviewed 14 July 2026. General information only, not personalised financial advice. Rules and data change; figures shown are illustrations, not forecasts.

Want to know what you're actually paying?

We'll pull the fees and the approach behind your current fund, compare them across the whole market, and tell you plainly whether it's worth what it costs. Free of charge.

Get a KiwiSaver recommendation

More questions on this and every other part of KiwiSaver are answered on our FAQs page.