Home/KiwiSaver Updates/Milford KiwiSaver Performance

Milford KiwiSaver Performance

Milford Recent Underperformance

For most of the last decade, Milford was the KiwiSaver manager to beat, with its funds regularly leading the pack over three, five and ten years. Over the past 12 to 18 months, however, that has changed, and Milford’s funds now sit near the bottom of their categories for one-year returns.

Over the year to 30 September 2026, the Milford Active Growth Fund returned 3.40%, compared with a median of 9.27% for growth funds. The Milford Balanced Fund returned 2.58%, against a median of 6.41% for balanced funds.

The longer-term picture, however, still looks strong for Milford. Over five years, both the Active Growth and Balanced funds are level with their category medians (7.13% vs 7.13%, and 5.52% vs 5.57%). Over ten years, both are still ahead (9.63% vs 8.82%, and 7.77% vs 7.03%).

Return period
Growth funds
Milford Active Growth
3.40%
Growth fund median
9.27%
Balanced funds
Milford Balanced
2.58%
Balanced fund median
6.41%
Milford fundCategory median

Why Milford has underperformed

Milford is an active manager. Its investment team decides what to hold and in what amounts, rather than simply tracking an index. That approach has served members well over the long term, but it means the fund’s returns can differ a lot from the market in any one year. The biggest factor recently has been the AI tech boom.

Index funds have ridden the AI tech boom. Much of the sharemarket’s gain over the past few years has come from a small group of very large US technology and AI companies. Index funds own these companies in proportion to their size, so as they have grown, index funds have become heavily weighted towards them and captured the full rally. Milford holds the same companies, but not at the concentrated weights they carry in the index, so it has missed part of those gains.

Why Milford holds less of the largest companies

There is a reason for that choice. The market has become unusually concentrated. The 10 largest companies now make up around 40% of the US S&P 500.

Holding the market at index weights today means a large bet on a handful of companies, one country and one sector. If expectations around AI aren’t met, those companies could fall together, and an index fund would feel the full impact. Milford deliberately spreads its investments across more sectors, regions and styles and pays attention to valuations, accepting that it will lag a narrow rally like this one in return for less exposure if it reverses.

History shows why concentration matters. The chart below compares today’s market with past periods when a single group of companies came to dominate.

10%20%30%40%50%60%70%Railroads: peak 63% (% US sharemarket)63%18351910Railroads% US sharemarketNifty Fifty: peak 40% (% S&P 500)40%19651981Nifty Fifty% S&P 500Japan: peak 44% (% global index)44%19811996Japan% global indexTech & telecom: peak 41% (% S&P 500)41%19942008Tech & telecom% S&P 500AI Big 10: peak 40% (% S&P 500)40%2019TodayAI Big 10% S&P 500
Lines are approximate, redrawn from BofA Global Investment Strategy and Bloomberg data; peak figures as published.

Each line shows how much of the market the leading group of the day made up. Railroads reached 63% of the US sharemarket in the late 1800s. The “Nifty Fifty” growth stocks reached 40% of the S&P 500 in 1973, Japanese shares 44% of the global index in 1989, and technology and telecom stocks 41% of the S&P 500 at the peak of the dot-com boom in 2000. Each time, concentration fell sharply afterwards, often as those leaders’ share prices fell back.

Today’s AI Big 10 has reached around 40% of the S&P 500, the same level as those past peaks. That doesn’t mean history will repeat, but it is exactly the kind of risk a diversified manager like Milford is trying to manage, and the main reason it has chosen not to hold these companies at full index weights.

Milford Fund built for smaller falls: Upside and downside capture

Milford’s approach is designed to give up some of the gains in strong markets in return for smaller falls in weak ones. One way to measure this is a capture ratio: how much of the market’s rises (upside capture) and falls (downside capture) a fund experiences.

Over the 10 years to 31 August 2026, the Milford Active Growth Fund captured about 91% of rising markets but only 77% of falling markets, after fees. A passive fund, by design, captures 100% of both.

0%20%40%60%80%100%120%3 years upside capture: 72%72%3 years downside capture: 60%60%3 years5 years upside capture: 79%79%5 years downside capture: 73%73%5 years10 years upside capture: 91%91%10 years downside capture: 77%77%10 yearsPassive fund upside capture: 100%100%Passive fund downside capture: 100%100%Passive fundUpside capture (share of market gains)Downside capture (share of market falls)
Source: Milford Asset Management, Morningstar Direct.

Milford does this partly by moving into cash when it sees risks that aren’t being rewarded. It lifted cash in the Active Growth Fund from around 10% to around 30% during the Covid selloff, to 23% in the 2022 inflation shock, and from about 8% to 19% ahead of the April 2025 US tariff announcement, then reinvested as markets recovered. Smaller falls matter because losses are harder to recover from: a 20% fall needs a 25% gain to get back to even, while a 50% fall needs 100%.

This is why we believe in fund manager diversification

Milford’s past year shows that even a manager with a strong long-term record will go through periods when its approach is out of step with the market. Active managers led for much of the last decade, while passive funds have led more recently. Nobody can reliably predict which approach, or which manager, will lead next.

That’s why we believe in fund manager diversification: holding a blend of different fund managers in your KiwiSaver portfolio, rather than relying on a single one.

  • A smoother ride. Different managers and styles tend to do well at different times. When one is lagging, another may be leading, which helps even out your returns over time.
  • The best of both approaches. A low-cost passive core captures the market’s returns, while active managers can aim to add value and cushion the blow when markets fall.
  • Less reliance on one team’s calls. If a single manager’s view turns out to be wrong, it only affects part of your savings, not all of it.
  • Fees kept in check. Combining lower-cost passive funds with selected active managers can bring your overall fee down compared with being fully active.

You can only belong to one KiwiSaver scheme at a time, but some schemes let you build your portfolio from funds run by several different managers, and multi-manager funds blend managers for you. The right mix depends on your timeframe, goals and risk tolerance.

Not sure if you’re in the right KiwiSaver fund?

Book a free independent KiwiSaver review. We compare the whole KiwiSaver market, at no cost to you.

Book a Free Review

Returns are to 30 September 2026, after fees and before tax. Past returns do not guarantee future returns. This is general information, not personalised financial advice.